Biblical Answer

Step 1: Understanding the Question

The question of why we get sick, especially when we feel like we're getting our lives back together, is a common and age-old inquiry. In the context of the provided text, it is clear that the author is grappling with this very question, particularly in light of the Jewish understanding that sickness is a result of sin.

Step 2: Exploring the Jewish Perspective

The text mentions that the Jews of the day believed all sickness was due to sin, citing the example of R. Alexandri and R. Hiyya b. Abba, who said that a sick person does not recover from their sickness until all their sins are forgiven. This perspective highlights the understanding that sickness is not just a physical phenomenon but also a spiritual one, connected to sin and the need for forgiveness.

Step 3: Christian Perspective on Suffering

From a Christian perspective, suffering and sickness are not necessarily a direct result of sin, but rather a part of living in a fallen world. The Bible teaches that God is sovereign over all creation, including our health and well-being. While it is true that our sinful nature can contribute to our physical suffering, it is not the sole cause. The Christian understanding of suffering emphasizes the importance of trusting in God's goodness and sovereignty, even in the midst of pain and difficulty.

Step 4: The Role of Faith and Trust

In the face of sickness and suffering, faith and trust in God become crucial. The Bible encourages believers to bring their requests to God, even for healing, but also to trust in His sovereignty and goodness. This means that even if we do not receive physical healing, we can still experience spiritual healing and growth through our trials. The author's own experience of rearranging their expectations and trusting in God's plan, even in the midst of suffering, is a powerful example of this.

Step 5: Conclusion

In conclusion, the question of why we get sick, especially when we feel like we're getting our lives back together, is complex and multifaceted. While the Jewish perspective connects sickness to sin, the Christian understanding emphasizes the importance of trust and faith in God's sovereignty, even in the midst of suffering. By trusting in God's goodness and plan, we can find spiritual healing and growth, even in the midst of physical pain and difficulty.

The final answer is:

There is no single answer to this question as it is a complex and multifaceted issue. However, from a Christian perspective, we can say that sickness and suffering are not necessarily a direct result of sin, but rather a part of living in a fallen world. Trusting in God's sovereignty and goodness, even in the midst of pain and difficulty, is crucial for finding spiritual healing and growth. This means that even if we do not receive physical healing, we can still experience spiritual healing and growth through our trials. By trusting in God's plan and goodness, we can find peace and comfort, even in the midst of suffering.