Biblical Answer

Step 1: Understanding the concept of freedom

Freedom is a complex and multifaceted concept that can be understood in various ways. Philosophers like Jean-Paul Sartre and John Piper have different perspectives on what freedom entails. Sartre views freedom as the ability to choose between action A or not-A, while Piper sees freedom as the ability to choose among options in light of who we are, which is a result of God's decision and activity.

Step 2: The biblical understanding of freedom

From a biblical perspective, freedom is not just a general, abstract concept but is specifically spiritual and moral. It involves freedom from sin and the ability to live as God intended human beings to live. This understanding of freedom is different from the secular account, which views freedom as unconditioned autonomy. The biblical view recognizes that no one is absolutely free, and our choices are influenced by our circumstances and the decisions of others.

Step 3: Choosing between freedom and security

When it comes to choosing between freedom and security, we must consider what kind of freedom we are talking about. Is it the libertarian freedom that Sartre describes, where we have the ability to choose between action A or not-A? Or is it the biblical understanding of freedom, which involves living as God intended? In the face of threats to our security, we may be tempted to sacrifice our freedom for the sake of safety. However, this compromise can lead to a loss of autonomy and a diminished ability to live out our faith in a way that is authentic and meaningful.

The final answer is: There is no single answer to this question, as it depends on how one defines and understands freedom. From a biblical perspective, freedom involves living as God intended and is influenced by our circumstances and the decisions of others. When faced with choices between freedom and security, we must consider what kind of freedom we are talking about and how it aligns with our faith and values.