Biblical Answer

The question of whether Eastern Orthodoxy is wrong is complex and multifaceted. From a biblical perspective, we must evaluate Eastern Orthodoxy based on its adherence to the authority of Scripture and its alignment with core Christian doctrines. While the Eastern Orthodox tradition has a rich history and has produced many notable theologians, there are several areas of concern that need to be addressed.

One of the primary concerns is the issue of authority. The Eastern Orthodox tradition places a strong emphasis on tradition and the decisions of the early Church councils, but it does not recognize the authority of the Pope or the Magisterium in the same way that Roman Catholicism does. This can lead to a lack of clarity and consistency in its teachings, particularly when it comes to core Christian doctrines such as the Trinity and the nature of Christ. For example, the Eastern Orthodox tradition has historically been influenced by Greek philosophical thought, which can sometimes lead to a more mystical or Platonic understanding of God and the world.

From a biblical perspective, the authority of Scripture must take precedence over tradition or the decisions of the early Church councils. The Bible is the inspired Word of God, and its teachings are authoritative and binding on all Christians. If Eastern Orthodoxy is to be considered a viable expression of Christianity, it must demonstrate a clear commitment to the authority of Scripture and a willingness to submit to its teachings, even when they may conflict with tradition or the decisions of the early Church councils. This is not to say that Eastern Orthodoxy is inherently wrong, but rather that it must be evaluated based on its adherence to biblical authority and its alignment with core Christian doctrines. Ultimately, the question of whether Eastern Orthodoxy is wrong will depend on how it responds to the challenges and criticisms that have been raised, and whether it is willing to submit to the authority of Scripture. I believe that if Eastern Orthodoxy continues to place tradition and the decisions of the early Church councils above the authority of Scripture, it will ultimately be seen as a heterodox expression of Christianity. But if it is willing to submit to the authority of Scripture and align its teachings with core Christian doctrines, then it may be considered a viable expression of Christianity.