Biblical Answer

The question with these physical treatments is not, Is this treatment right or wrong? The question is, Is this treatment wise? The guidelines of wisdom apply. For some treatments, such as moderate exercise, the benefits are clear and well-established. However, for other treatments, such as certain medications, the efficacy and safety may be uncertain, and the decision to use them may depend on a condition that may not be fulfilled. In such cases, the application of a treatment may not be wise.

The issue of treating depression is a good illustration of this. While physical treatments may alleviate some of the physical symptoms of depression, they do not address the underlying spiritual symptoms, such as guilt, fear, and self-loathing. The focus on physical treatments can lead to a neglect of the deeper issues that are at the root of the problem. This is why it is essential to consider the spiritual dimension of depression and to address the underlying causes of the problem.

In the context of depression, the question of responsibility for the cause and cure is also relevant. While it is true that depression can be caused by a combination of physical and spiritual factors, the spiritual dimension is often overlooked. As Job notes, "Why?" is a more urgent question than "How?" or "When?" In other words, we need to ask why depression is happening, rather than just treating the symptoms. This requires a deeper understanding of the spiritual causes of depression and a willingness to address them. Ultimately, the cure for depression lies not just in physical treatments, but in a deeper understanding of our spiritual condition and a willingness to seek healing and restoration through Christ. I believe that this is the heart of the matter, and it is essential to address the deeper issues that are at the root of depression.